Are you originally from the United Kingdom and considering working in France ? You are probably familiar with the umbrella company model, that intermediary structure allowing you to work as a freelancer while enjoying employee status. France has an equivalent: the portage salarial.
Both systems share the same founding logic: offering a third way between traditional employment and full self-employment. Yet they diverge on several essential points. What are the differences between these two models? That is what we will detail in this article.
The umbrella company emerged in the United Kingdom in the 1990s, in a context marked by the rise of independent workers, particularly in the technology and finance sectors. While the model was born in the early 1990s, it truly established itself in the early 2000s.
In 1999, the British government introduced IR35 to prevent self-employed workers from benefiting from the tax advantages linked to paying dividends through a limited company — notably the exemption from National Insurance contributions. This legislation drove the rapid rise of umbrella companies.
Indeed, before this law, many freelancers, rather than paying themselves a salary (subject to income tax and contributions) were paying themselves dividends, which were far less taxed and exempt from National Insurance. A freelancer who was in practice working like an employee was therefore paying significantly lower charges than a genuine employee. With IR35, freelancers could no longer optimise their pay through dividends, which is why many of them turned to umbrella companies.
Emerging in the 1980s to allow experienced executives to resume professional activity after a period of unemployment, the portage salarial long operated in a legal vacuum. The Labour Market Modernisation Act of 2008 granted it its first official recognition, followed by the ordinance of 2 April 2015, which laid the foundations of its legal framework: a definition of the arrangement, operating conditions for portage companies, and the rights and obligations of each party.
Finally, the national collective agreement of 22 March 2017, extended by ministerial decree, completed this framework by setting precise rules on minimum remuneration, employment contracts, and social guarantees.
Today, the portage salarial is defined by La convention collective du portage salarial as « a set of contractual relationships organised between a portage company, a ported worker, and client companies, » enabling an individual to carry out assignments for a client company while remaining an employee of the portage company.
At first glance, portage salarial and umbrella company appear to rest on the same principle: an intermediary company employs a freelance worker and manages the contractual relationships with the client. But behind this apparent similarity lie major differences.
The intermediaries
The portage salarial is based on a three-way relationship between a freelancer, a portage company, and a client company. This relationship is governed by la convention collective du portage salarial and cannot be modified under any circumstances.
In umbrella companies, while the tripartite relationship does exist, a fourth intermediary often enters the picture: the recruitment agency. This agency directly approaches client companies in need of contractors, handling all sourcing activities : job postings, profile matching, interview coordination, and so on. For the vast majority of IT and tech freelancers, going through an agency is in practice unavoidable: many companies do not publicly advertise their needs, and accessing the best assignments without an intermediary remains very difficult.
This is arguably the most significant difference between the two.
The French portage salarial is underpinned by a comprehensive legal framework: the 2015 ordinance, the 2017 convention collective, and dedicated articles within the French Labour Code. Each portage company is subject to strict obligations ( mandatory financial guarantees, guaranteed minimum remuneration, compulsory registration), and so on. The ported consultant knows exactly what they are entitled to and has clear legal recourse in the event of a dispute.
The umbrella company, by contrast, operates within a fragmented and variable legal environment. In the United Kingdom, practices are governed by specific tax rules — notably IR35 legislation, which determines whether a freelancer should be treated as an employee for tax purposes — but without any equivalent to the French social framework.
This is where the gap between the two models is most visible, and most consequential for the worker. In portage salarial, the consultant benefits from comprehensive social protection, identical to that of any employee in France:
With an umbrella company, social protection depends entirely on the company chosen. In the United Kingdom, certain rights do exist ( National Insurance contributions, statutory paid leave ) but they remain significantly below French standards, particularly regarding pensions, sickness reimbursements, and income protection coverage. In countries with less developed frameworks, coverage can be virtually non-existent.
For a freelance worker, the question of a safety net between assignments is central and this is one of the key strengths of the portage salarial.
Under portage salarial, the ported consultant contributes to France Travail like any employee. In the event of a mission ending without renewal, they may (subject to contribution period conditions) claim unemployment benefit (the ARE). This is a considerable advantage that no other self-employed status in France offers, neither the micro-entreprise nor the SASU without a specific arrangement.
With an umbrella company, access to unemployment insurance is either non-existent or very limited. In the United Kingdom, for example, umbrella contractors are eligible for Universal Credit, a social assistance benefit far less generous than the French ARE. For a French resident going through a foreign umbrella company, access to French unemployment benefit is simply unavailable.
In both cases, the worker receives a net salary after deduction of social charges and the intermediary’s management fees. But the financial models differ.
Under portage salarial, management fees are deducted from the consultant’s pre-tax revenue (CA HT) and generally range from 5% to 15% depending on the company and the level of services provided. The remainder is subject to standard employer and employee social contributions, then paid out as a net salary. On average, the consultant can expect to receive between 45% and 55% of their pre-tax revenue as net pay, depending on their level of charges and their management of professional expenses.
With an umbrella company, the billing model may be a percentage of gross income or a fixed weekly or monthly fee. However, the conversion to net remuneration depends heavily on the local social charges and the umbrella’s own fees. In some cases, opaque practices ? such as remuneration schemes via non-taxable loans or advances, were used to artificially inflate the net amount received, before being heavily penalised by British tax authorities, notably through the Loan Charge.
The portage salarial is reserved for expert intellectual services carried out autonomously for client companies (B2B).
To use portage salarial, the consultant must hold a level 5 qualification (equivalent to a two-year post-secondary degree) and must be capable of finding their own assignments independently. The collective agreement sets a minimum gross monthly salary of €2,517.13, which in practice excludes junior profiles or low-volume activity. The most represented sectors are:
Worth noting: in France, certain activities are not compatible with portage salarial:
The umbrella company caters to a far broader range of activities than the portage salarial. It encompasses both highly qualified profiles (IT, finance, engineering) and workers in more manual or operational sectors:
There is no minimum remuneration threshold imposed by a legal framework equivalent to the French collective agreement. This makes the umbrella company accessible to more junior profiles or short-duration, lower-value assignments.
The portage salarial is designed for experts selling their expertise to businesses. The umbrella company, on the other hand, can accommodate a far more heterogeneous range of profiles. If you are an experienced consultant wishing to work in France, the portage salarial is tailored to your profile.
Portage salarial and umbrella company address the same need: working as a freelancer without giving up the security of employee status. But they are not suited to the same context, nor do they offer the same level of protection.
If you are working in France, the portage salarial is unquestionably the most coherent choice. Its solid legal framework, comprehensive social protection, access to unemployment insurance, and entitlement to the Compte Personnel de Formation (personal training account) make it an unmatched arrangement for a freelancer seeking to secure their career over the long term. It is the ideal solution, in particular, for a British professional relocating to France: it enables immediate access to the French social protection system, with no break in entitlements and no fiscal grey area.
The umbrella company, for its part, remains relevant in a British context, but its considerable variability, depending on the provider and local legislation, calls for heightened vigilance: not all models are equal, and certain schemes have proven very costly to those who used them.
SUIVEZ-NOUS
Qui sommes-nous ?
